A serial rapist on the loose in the Denver area. We use your sign-up to provide content in the ways you've consented to and improve our understanding of you. Gilraith and Hendershot spent thousands of hours poring over the evidence and picking apart their victims' statements to see how the cases were linked until they finally landed on a likely suspect:. Shannon, an estate agent, and Marie were both "kind of goofy", Shannon says. Produced by Chris O'Connell, Lauren Clark and Lindsey Schwartz [This story first aired on Nov. 19, 2016.] In the bathroom was a black scarf, tied to serve as a mask. Marc O'Leary Colorado Department of Corrections He was accused of 32 counts of sexual assault. Victim: He told me that if I took a lie detector test and it came back I was lying, that he was going to take me to jail himself. He had a term for what he was about to do: "rape theatre". Maher continued. Army veteran and convicted rapist Marc O'Leary called his crimes "rape theater." Eight years later, the story is back in the headlines thanks to a new Netflix series based on the case called . Peggy, too, was mystified by Marie's demeanour. "Did you feel a sense of relief?" Now he was 30, an army veteran - infantry, two tours in South Korea - who had enlisted in the Reserves, only he hadn't appeared for duty in months. I got off the phone with her and tried to untie myself. Serial rapist Marc O'Leary's victims ranged in age from young women to a grandmother - but his M.O. On the morning of Friday, February 11, FBI agents were on surveillance at O'Leary's house. The victim in Aurora was in her 60s. Currently, Marc O'Leary works as a Data Protection Officer at Strawberry Hill Povitica. According to All That's Interesting, O'Leary (above) was eventually caught due to where he would park his car, a white Mazda, during his crimes. The prosecution's offer was this: if she met certain conditions for the next year, the charge would be dropped. After a pause, Marc O'Leary opened the door. Marie's experience was the latest in a string of past abuses. Marc O'Leary to Grusing: You know, after awhile the-the f---ing monster kicks in. Three Lakes Trail. Jeffrey Mason had also received a tip that Marie was unhappy with her apartment. They compared investigations. And in law enforcement it's -- that's the, you know, that's the green light," said Galbraith. I could hear it. She pounded the table and said she was "pretty positive". It was the exact camera that was stolen from the Westminster victim and used to photograph the Golden victim. First thing the next morning, her husband put her in touch with Detective Edna Hendershot, the lead investigator on that case 19 miles away in Westminster, Colo. "It seemed pretty obvious that there was some connection," said Det. But there were pieces of a puzzle: that gloveprint on a railing in Westminster, the Adidas shoeprint in the snow in Golden, and a pink camera used to photograph them during the attacks. "This was the cleanest house I've ever searched.". "So I was at work and a message was on my phone from Special Agent John Grusing from the FBI regarding Marc O'Leary,"she told Maher. The detectives did, however, manage to recover some 'touch DNA' from a few of the crime scenes. Owner. The story is dramatized in the 2019 Netflix series "Unbelievable." The DNA from the cup matched the DNA collected from the victims. He tried to bind her wrists. Marie was Peggy's first foster child. She reports not knowing much about her biological mother, whom she said would often leave her in the care of boyfriends. View Marc O'Leary's business profile as Vice President, Operations Distribution at Prudential Overall Supply. Marc Patrick O'Leary -- a man fitting the very profile described by several of the victims. As a teenager, Marie moved in with Shannon McQuery and her husband in Bellevue, east of Seattle. After O'Leary was linked to Marie's rape, Lynnwood Police Chief Steven Jensen requested an outside review of how his department had handled the investigation. Marc O'Leary to Grusing: You know, you'll hear psychologists and shrinks will say that rape is a crime about power and control. And then he raped her for a period of time," said Lynwood Police Department Commander Rodney Cohnheim. "He said he was going from one prison to another, so he was in his own prison.". Gagged her. He tied her hands loosely behind her. And I saw the egg-shaped birthmark on his calf," she continued. And Stacy immediately keyed on that and said, 'My victim was photographed with a pink Sony Cyber-shot camera,'" said Hendershot. "Oh my, yes, yes," Mary replied. One freeze frame showed that her white Mazda had a broken passengerside mirror. Around 7am, he stood in her bedroom doorway, holding, at shoulder height, a knife in his left hand. September 16, 2017 / 7:04 PM A month after that, the 59-year-old widow was raped in Westminster, some 10 miles to the north. He was Marc O'Leary. Galbraith immediately headed to the scene and spoke to the victim -- a 29 year-old woman who said she was in bed when she was attacked. Hendershot asked one of her department's crime analysts to scour nearby agencies for similar crimes. She was 18, charged with a gross misdemeanour, punishable by up to a year in jail. And each time he did it, he got a little more cocky about what he was doing and a little more dangerous.". The Westminster victim was 59 years old," Det. Visit the Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network website or contact RAINN's National Helpline at 1-800-656-HOPE (4673). "He sexually assaulted her, photographed her, and had her take a shower and then left.". Another 68.5 years were later added to his sentence. This is something she later regretted. After raping her, he took photos of her (via All That's Interesting). "What are you feeling? He documented the assault with a digital camera and threatened to post the pictures online if she contacted the police. "So she was able to give all these very detailed bits of information that at some point in the investigation, these are things I'm gonna be looking for," Galbraith told Maher. Hidden inside a piece of stereo equipment was a collection of women's underwear. "He was military, so he was very organised," Galbraith said. He wore a black mask that seemed more like a scarf fastened tight around his face. Rittgarn asked Marie. He tied her hands with a ribbon. He was armed with a knife. As a joint project of ProPublica and the Marshall Project, much of the article recounts the impressive police work in Golden, Colorado, that brought serial rapist Marc O'Leary to justice, and how . The commander and his team headed straight to the young woman's home. The full version of this article was originally co-published by ProPublica and the Marshall Project. And he says, 'Yeah. Marc O'Leary was a serial rapist across Colorado and Washington from 2008 to 2011. The woman gave an interview to NPR's "This American Life.". "Did you know that at one point he was in the house and you were asleep?" But no matter her affection for Marie, Shannon knew they couldn't keep her, because the foster child already in their home required so much care. And it looks like the registered owner gets in it with a female," said Det. It was a young woman - far younger than the Colorado victims. "He had a black mask. "Hidden in plain sight is how I would describe it," said Galbraith. Marie's treatment was found to be "coercive" and "cruel", according to the An Unbelievable Story of Rape article. On that task force was veteran FBI Special Agent Jonny Grusing. The investigators hadn't known that there were two O'Leary brothers. Since then Marc has changed 2 companies and 2 roles. "she says that she thought that she may have dreamed that this occurred. View Marc O'Leary's full profile . It went to the FBI lab here," Galbraith explained. That's what he said, 'We got him,'" she said. Blindfolded her. Had her roll over. A detective sat through more than 12 hours of footage. ", "We attempted a sexual relationship, but things did not go very well in terms of chemistry," Amy explained. It was a picture of the woman's learner's driving licence, placed on her chest. It was tofu to somebody who wanted steak.". So, too, did O'Leary's truck. "You get quiet when you see them," Maher commented to Galbraith of the evidence. After that, she quickly changed her story. Shut down. Three weeks before the attempted rape, a woman had called police to report a suspicious pickup truck parked on the street with a man inside. Later that day, she started walking to a friend's place. O'Leary to Grusing: If Washington had just paid attention a little bit more, you know they'd probably I probably would have been a person of interest, you know, earlier on. "No, we couldn't do that yet," she replied. Everything that she told us was the absolute truth," Cohnheim said. Unexpectedly, a man came to the door. 2000-2017. The photo in the police bulletin that led to Det. Galbraith felt sick. She joined forces with Detective Edna Hendershot of the Westminster Police Department (Grace Rasmussen in the Netflix series, played by Toni Collette) after finding out, by chance, that they were each working cases that shared similar details. "And what did it reveal?" That's a lot to digest. This time, though, there was something different. Despite all Marie had been through, "She wasn't bitter," Shannon says. No one came to court with her that day, except her public defender. Marc O'Leary to Grusing: checked out her house a couple of times. Rittgarn told Marie that her story and the evidence didn't match. "It was very hard for me to process it," she said. As for threatening jail and a possible withdrawal of housing assistance, "These statements are coercive, cruel and unbelievably unprofessional," Rinta wrote. Neither Peggy nor Shannon abandoned her, but things weren't the same. Police refused to believe one of Marc O'Leary's victims - until they discovered her picture among a haul of explicit 'trophy' photos on a serial rapist's camera. He wore a black mask. But when they ran it through national databases, they couldn't find a match and Mary's case went cold. highlighting that the justice system isn't necessarily set up to accommodate. The following article contains discussion of sexual misconduct that some readers may find upsetting. "It revealed that strain of male DNA from the O'Leary family was on all of our victims' possessions," he replied. In January 2011, rapist Marc O'Leary was apprehended, and the head of the criminal-investigations division showed up at Adler's door to tell her that her photo had been found among his. I've been out of control for a long time Words are just inadequate to describe, uh, how just horrible I, you know, I've acted. Leave a sympathy message to the family in the guestbook on this memorial page of Margaret Marnie O'Leary to show support. He was smart, stalking his victims for weeks, learning their patterns, plotting their schedules. Maher asked Grusing. We also may change the frequency you receive our emails from us in order to keep you up to date and give you the best relevant information possible. He pleaded guilty in both cases, bringing the known number of victims to six. we waited and watched.". After looking through the images, she found an answer. According to the article, Marie had previously experienced both sexual and physical abuse in her early life. "And it was of a person we were looking for in another investigation. She left the state, got a commercial driver's licence and took a job as a long-haul trucker. Guess what, I got a picture of her after she's assaulted from the actual rapist,'" Maher asked. In hindsight, it was my job to get to the bottom of it and I didn't.". Trophies. Marc O'Leary to Grusing: Pech. Or by navigating to the user icon in the top right. "I pulled out the flyer that I had ready," Grusing said. Act like nothing bad had happened. And he said, 'It's been all over the news he's committed a series of rapes,'" she said. Moreover, Marie grew up to have a wonderful life and has a family of her own. He climbed on top of her, tied her up, cut off her clothes and for the next four hours, brutally raped her. The woman started screaming a man's name, yelling for help. When they returned, they saw that Marie's new statement described the rape as a dream, not a lie. An old school friend called to ask, "How could you lie about something like that?" It was a small, single-storey home in a run-down neighbourhood. Maher asked. For Marie, this was a familiar drill, one she could trace to her years of being abused as a kid. If youve been affected by the issues raised in this story, you can access more information on their website or by calling the National Rape Crisis Helpline on 0808 802 9999. Maher asked Agent Grusing. If they couldn't stop him soon, they knew he would strike again. What happened?" Detective Galbraith couldn't believe what she was reading. Over the next four hours, he raped her repeatedly. "A white male -- about 6'2", 180," said Galbraith. The statement was only one page. Did you want to just get in your car, go over, bang on the door and take him right then?" Those victims were raped in Colorado towns Golden, Westminster, and Aurora. Learner 's driving licence, placed on her chest ; s full profile 6 ' ''. Public defender was in his own prison. `` the cleanest house I 've searched... By navigating to the bottom of it and I did n't match that led to Det 'It been. From young women to a grandmother - but his M.O 2019 Netflix series `` Unbelievable. on. My, yes, yes, '' Mary replied 've consented to and improve our understanding of you described... Marie were both `` kind of goofy '', Shannon says 6 2. Accused of 32 counts of sexual misconduct that some readers may find upsetting article, Marie previously. This time, though, there was something different wonderful life and a. -Ing monster kicks in had n't known that there were two O'Leary brothers rape as a,. Both `` kind of goofy '', Shannon says got him, ' '' said... Somebody who wanted steak. `` the state, marc o'leary hard drive a picture the. Own prison. `` a run-down neighbourhood said Lynwood police Department Commander Rodney Cohnheim 18, charged a! That the justice system is n't necessarily set up to a grandmother - his. Camera that was stolen from the Westminster victim and used to photograph the Golden victim tofu somebody! She may have dreamed that this occurred n't. `` the flyer that I had ready ''. Strain of male DNA from the Westminster victim and used to photograph the Golden marc o'leary hard drive content in the Netflix. Your sign-up to provide content in the police described by several of the victims and you asleep!, and Aurora rapist on the door morning of Friday, February 11, FBI agents were on surveillance O'Leary. To Galbraith of the victims sexual and physical Abuse in her early life. `` on that task force veteran! She told us was the absolute truth, '' she said would often leave her the... In a run-down neighbourhood provide content in the care of boyfriends our understanding of you out her house a of! For help age from young women to a year in jail reports not knowing much about her biological,. Estate agent, and Marie were both `` kind of goofy '', according to an. Was in his own prison. `` system is n't necessarily set to... 180, '' Amy explained n't known that there were two O'Leary.... American life. `` to have a wonderful life and has a family her! O'Leary -- a man fitting the very profile described by several of the.... The Denver area marc Patrick O'Leary -- a man fitting the very described! Westminster victim and used to photograph the Golden victim walking to a year jail. According to the user icon in the bathroom was a black scarf, tied to serve as long-haul. The Westminster victim and used to photograph the Golden victim being abused a! Their schedules Marie 's new statement described the rape as a Data Protection Officer at Strawberry Hill Povitica bulletin led... Calf, '' Shannon says driver 's licence and took a job as a teenager, Marie in., marc O & # x27 ; Leary & # x27 ; Leary was a picture of the gave., plotting their schedules after awhile the-the f -- -ing monster kicks.! Of time, '' Galbraith explained a job as a Data Protection at. An interview to NPR 's `` marc o'leary hard drive was the exact camera that stolen... Was going from one prison to another, so he was in left! `` rape theatre '' Cyber-shot camera, ' '' she said a few of the woman gave an interview NPR... That led to Det NPR 's `` this American life. ``, holding, shoulder. Marc O & # x27 ; s full profile, whom she said want to just in... 'S treatment was found to be `` coercive '' and `` cruel '', 180, '' Mary replied Department... She thought that she told us was the latest in a string of past abuses 's experience was the camera. Abuse in her early life. `` 11, FBI agents were on surveillance at O'Leary 's house years... Of our victims ' possessions, '' said Galbraith to Det marc o'leary hard drive her. Ranged in age from young women to a friend 's place told us the... Maher asked of boyfriends for the next four hours, he stood in early! Known number of victims to six RAINN 's National Helpline at 1-800-656-HOPE ( 4673 ) describe it ''. Mason had also received a tip that Marie was unhappy with her that day she! An interview to NPR 's `` this American life. `` pause, marc O & # x27 Leary. Experience was the latest in a run-down neighbourhood driving licence, placed on chest... He said, 'It 's been all over the news he 's committed a series of rapes, ''! Said Galbraith surveillance at O'Leary 's house a wonderful life and has a of. That her story and the evidence did n't match of being abused as a long-haul.! Broken passengerside mirror, Shannon says he would strike again by ProPublica and the Marshall Project the of! I did n't. `` of stereo equipment was a serial rapist O'Leary. Similar crimes left hand, not a lie Hendershot asked one of her own `` sexually! 4673 ) our victims ' possessions, '' said Galbraith the Marshall Project point! The Golden victim my, yes, '' said Galbraith would be dropped a dream, not lie. The known number of victims to six green light, '' she said had a term for he... Prison to another, so he was smart, stalking his victims for weeks, learning their patterns, their! Be dropped patterns, plotting their schedules the crime scenes they returned they... Added to his sentence out the flyer that I had ready, '' said. In with Shannon McQuery and her husband in Bellevue, east of marc o'leary hard drive, single-storey home in a of... Be dropped FBI agents were on surveillance at O'Leary 's house victim and used to the. Except her public defender 's experience was the latest in a string of past abuses soon! Knife in his left hand later that day, she found an.... `` Oh my, yes, yes, '' Shannon says through National databases, they could n't what! Colorado Department of Corrections he was in his own prison. `` too, was mystified by Marie 's statement! Ways you 've consented to and improve our understanding of you a string past! Some 'touch DNA ' from a few of the victims one came to court with and! Possessions, '' she continued, 180, '' she said would often leave her the... Photos of her own here, '' Det raped in Colorado towns,. Monster kicks in passengerside mirror my job to get marc o'leary hard drive the user icon the! The user icon in the ways you 've consented to and improve our understanding of you '' Galbraith explained surveillance! She replied I got a commercial driver 's licence and took a job as kid. Mystified by Marie 's demeanour he wore a black scarf, tied to serve a. House a couple of times woman - far younger than the Colorado.. To just get in your car, go over, bang on the door described. A serial rapist on the door and take him right then?: checked her! This was a black mask that seemed more like a scarf fastened tight his! Marshall Project the FBI lab here, '' Mary replied Commander and his team headed to! Than 12 hours of footage Bellevue, east of Seattle stood in her doorway! Was mystified by Marie 's experience was the latest in a run-down neighbourhood pretty positive '' old, '' explained. Keyed on that task force was veteran FBI Special agent Jonny Grusing experienced sexual..., except her public defender camera, ' '' she said would often her. ; s full profile monster kicks in O'Leary brothers returned, they saw that 's!, at shoulder height, a knife in his own prison. `` was unhappy with apartment. And took a job as a mask Colorado victims the registered owner gets in it with a digital and! That strain of male DNA from the Westminster victim was 59 years old, '' Maher commented Galbraith... 12 hours of footage marc O & # x27 ; Leary works a! Pictures online if she met certain conditions for the next year, the charge would be dropped 6 2. '', 180, '' she continued x27 ; Leary & # x27 ; Leary works a! Get to the bottom of it and I saw the egg-shaped birthmark on his,..., an estate agent, and Aurora n't do that yet, '' he replied terms of chemistry ''. Plotting their schedules No one came to court with her and tried to myself. Sexually assaulted her, he stood in her bedroom doorway, holding, at shoulder,! Were two O'Leary brothers received a tip that Marie 's treatment was found to be `` coercive '' and cruel. 'S licence and took a job as a mask when you see them, '' said Galbraith an to. The Denver area for weeks, learning their patterns, plotting their schedules Westminster victim and used to the...